€41,434 WRC Award: Why a Sick Leave Clause Wasn’t Enough to Justify Dismissal
An aviation company has been ordered to pay €41,434.08 following the unfair dismissal of a long-serving employee while he was on certified sick leave. The Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) found that relying on a contractual provision concerning incapacity did not remove the employer’s obligation to follow fair procedures.
Long-term employee absence can create difficult operational challenges for employers.
Businesses may need to redistribute responsibilities, make temporary staffing arrangements or consider whether an employee will be able to return to their role.
However, even where an employment contract contains provisions allowing termination following extended illness, employers must still ensure that any dismissal is substantively and procedurally fair.
This was highlighted in a recent WRC decision, ADJ-00049248, involving Magellan Aviation Services and a former senior executive who had worked with the business for approximately 33 years.
The WRC found that the employer’s handling of the employee’s absence and subsequent dismissal fell short of what would be expected of a reasonable employer.
The employee was awarded €41,434.08 net in compensation for unfair dismissal.
What Happened?
The complainant, Gerry Burke, commenced employment with Magellan Aviation Services on 15 October 1990.
He was a founding shareholder of the business and had previously served as Managing Director.
Following the acquisition of the company by Japanese conglomerate Marubeni Corporation, he continued working in a senior role as Director of Special Projects.
By 2023, significant disagreements had developed between the employee and the employer.
These included disputes concerning contractual arrangements, remuneration and the employee’s tax status following his relocation to Malta.
The employee also initiated separate legal proceedings relating to aspects of those disputes.
In March 2023, the employee went on certified sick leave following health difficulties and surgery.
He remained absent over the following months.
On 8 August 2023, after approximately 154 days of certified sick leave, the employer terminated his employment.
The company relied on a provision contained in the employee’s employment contract.
What Did the Employment Contract Say?
The employee’s contract contained a provision under which extended absence due to ill health could result in the employee being deemed permanently incapacitated.
The relevant definition treated incapacity lasting 60 consecutive days or 120 aggregate days within a 12-month period as permanent incapacity for contractual purposes.
A separate clause permitted the employer to terminate employment on grounds of disability by providing 30 days’ written notice.
The employer argued that the employee’s absence exceeded the contractual threshold and that termination was therefore permitted.
Its position was that the contract specifically addressed prolonged absence and that the employer had acted in accordance with those agreed terms.
The company also argued that it had provided a payment equivalent to three months’ notice, exceeding the contractual notice requirement.
However, the central question for the WRC was not simply whether the contractual provision existed.
It was whether reliance on that provision was sufficient to establish a fair dismissal under the Unfair Dismissals Acts.
Why Did the WRC Find the Dismissal Unfair?
Adjudication Officer Ewa Sobanska found significant shortcomings in the process used to terminate the employee’s employment.
Although the employee had been absent on certified sick leave, the employer had not adequately investigated his medical circumstances or engaged with him about his potential return.
The WRC identified several important failings.
1. No meaningful assessment of the employee’s medical position
The employer had relied on the duration of the employee’s absence and the wording of his contract.
However, it had not made adequate enquiries about his health status, prognosis or likely return-to-work date.
The WRC emphasised that employers considering dismissal because of long-term illness should make reasonable efforts to assess the employee’s medical circumstances rather than assuming an employee is permanently unable to work.
2. No advance warning that dismissal was being considered
The employee was not informed in advance that his continued employment was at risk because of his absence.
This meant he was not given a meaningful opportunity to address the potential dismissal before the decision was made.
In cases involving capability or incapacity, fair procedures require an employer to communicate the concern and allow the employee an opportunity to respond.
3. No adequate consultation about returning to work
The employer had not engaged with the employee about his potential return to work or explored the circumstances surrounding his continued absence.
The absence of meaningful consultation was particularly important given his long service and the seriousness of the proposed decision.
4. No opportunity to appeal
The employee’s dismissal took effect immediately, and he was not offered an appeal against the decision.
The absence of an appeal was another procedural weakness considered by the WRC.
5. Other unresolved workplace disputes
The WRC also examined the wider circumstances surrounding the dismissal.
Relations between the employee and the employer had deteriorated significantly, with ongoing disagreements over remuneration, contractual arrangements and related legal issues.
An attempt at mediation concerning those disputes had concluded shortly before the dismissal.
The Adjudication Officer was not satisfied that those other matters had played no part in the decision to terminate employment.
Importantly, she was not satisfied that the dismissal resulted wholly or mainly from the employee’s capability to perform his work.
Taking these matters together, the WRC concluded that the dismissal was unfair.
Does a Contractual Termination Clause Protect an Employer?
This is one of the most significant lessons from the decision.
The fact that an employment contract provides for termination in particular circumstances does not necessarily mean that exercising that provision will result in a fair dismissal.
Employers must consider both their contractual rights and their statutory obligations.
Under the Unfair Dismissals Acts 1977–2015, an employer must be able to establish substantial grounds justifying a dismissal.
Capability, including incapacity arising from ill health, can potentially constitute a fair reason for dismissal.
However, the employer must also act reasonably and follow appropriate procedures.
A provision stating that an employee may be dismissed after a specified period of illness should not be treated as an automatic substitute for medical assessment, consultation and fair decision-making.
The key distinction is between having a contractual power to terminate employment and exercising that power in a legally fair manner.
Can an Employer Dismiss an Employee on Long-Term Sick Leave?
Yes. Dismissal during long-term sick leave is not automatically unlawful.
There may be circumstances where an employee is unable to perform the essential duties of their role and there is no reasonable prospect of returning to work within an acceptable timeframe.
However, employers should carefully examine the circumstances before reaching that conclusion.
Depending on the case, relevant considerations may include:
- The employee’s current medical position and prognosis.
- The likely duration of the absence.
- The employee’s ability to carry out the essential duties of their role.
- The operational impact of the continued absence.
- Whether reasonable adjustments, workplace supports or suitable alternatives are available.
- The employee’s response and representations.
- Whether the proposed decision is proportionate and supported by evidence.
Where the employee’s condition amounts to a disability under the Employment Equality Acts, additional obligations concerning reasonable accommodation may arise.
The precise requirements depend on the circumstances.
Employers should not assume that receiving medical certificates confirming an employee’s absence is equivalent to having a proper assessment of their long-term capability to return.
What About the Employee Working Outside Ireland?
The case also involved an unusual preliminary legal issue.
The employee had relocated to Malta several years before his dismissal and worked internationally.
The employer argued that the protections of the Irish Unfair Dismissals Act did not apply because the employee ordinarily worked outside Ireland and resided abroad.
However, the WRC examined the employee’s longstanding connections with Ireland, including his domicile and intentions concerning his permanent home.
It determined that he remained legally domiciled in Ireland and could pursue his unfair dismissal complaint.
This aspect of the decision is particularly relevant to employers with internationally mobile executives or employees working across jurisdictions.
However, it should not be interpreted as meaning that every employee working overseas for an Irish company will automatically be covered by Irish unfair dismissal legislation.
Cross-border employment arrangements require consideration of the employee’s circumstances, the relevant contract and the applicable legal rules.
Why Was the Award €41,434 Rather Than the Larger Amount Claimed?
The employee sought reinstatement and advanced a financial claim valued at more than €1.2 million.
However, the WRC did not accept that the evidence supported the remuneration and loss calculations presented.
In particular, it found insufficient documentary evidence to substantiate the proposed bonus figures.
The employee had also sought reinstatement to his former position.
The WRC declined that remedy, finding that the relationship between the parties had deteriorated so significantly that the mutual trust and confidence necessary for a return to employment no longer existed.
The Adjudication Officer therefore considered compensation the appropriate remedy.
She also examined the employee’s efforts to minimise his financial losses following dismissal.
The WRC found that he had not provided sufficient evidence of reasonable efforts to secure alternative employment.
This affected the amount awarded.
Ultimately, the WRC directed the employer to pay €41,434.08 net, equivalent to approximately six months’ base salary.
The award reflected the unfair dismissal, while also taking account of the employee’s inadequate efforts to mitigate his loss and earnings received following termination.
The separate Payment of Wages Act complaint had been withdrawn and was not determined as part of the decision.
Five Practical Lessons for Irish Employers
1. Review contractual termination clauses carefully
Employment contracts should not be treated as overriding statutory employment protections.
Before relying on any clause permitting termination following illness or incapacity, employers should consider whether the proposed action would satisfy the Unfair Dismissals Acts and other applicable legislation.
2. Obtain appropriate medical information
Where an employee has been absent for an extended period, the employer should consider whether further medical information or an occupational health assessment is necessary.
The purpose should be to understand the employee’s ability to perform their role, their likely return-to-work timeframe and any relevant supports.
Any assessment or processing of medical information should be handled appropriately and in accordance with applicable privacy obligations.
3. Consult before making a final decision
An employee should be made aware when their continued employment is being considered because of long-term incapacity.
They should have a meaningful opportunity to respond, provide relevant information and discuss possible arrangements.
Employers should avoid presenting a decision as final before an appropriate process has taken place.
4. Keep underlying disputes separate
Where there are existing disagreements about pay, contracts, management or workplace relationships, employers should take particular care when considering dismissal.
The decision should be supported by the genuine reason relied upon, rather than becoming an indirect means of resolving an unrelated dispute.
Clear records and appropriate separation of issues can be particularly important.
5. Document the decision and provide appropriate procedural safeguards
Employers should be able to demonstrate what information was considered, what consultation occurred, what alternatives were assessed and why the ultimate decision was reached.
An appropriate opportunity to challenge or appeal the decision can also be an important safeguard.
Where a dismissal proceeds to the WRC, the employer may need to explain both the reason for the decision and the process followed.
For practical guidance on responding to employment claims, see our article: Received a WRC Complaint? 7 Things Employers Should Do Before the Hearing.
The Wider Lesson for Employers
This decision does not mean an employee can never be dismissed while on sick leave.
It demonstrates that long-term absence should not automatically be treated as permanent incapacity simply because a contractual threshold has been reached.
The employer must still establish that the dismissal is justified and that the process followed is fair.
The significant deterioration in workplace relationships also demonstrates why employers should be careful about making employment decisions while other serious disputes remain unresolved.
A contract may describe when termination can be considered. It does not remove the need to establish why dismissal is justified and how a fair decision should be reached.
For employers and HR professionals, the best protection is a clear, evidence-based process supported by proper communication, appropriate medical information and sound decision-making.
Managing Long-Term Absence or Facing an Employment Claim?
Long-term employee absence can create difficult questions around capability, workplace responsibilities, return-to-work arrangements and the future of an employment relationship.
At Employment Matters, we assist employers and HR teams with workplace disputes, employment claims, fair procedures and practical workplace solutions.
Where a dismissal is being challenged, our Defending a Legal Claim service can help employers assess the circumstances, review the evidence and consider an appropriate response under an agreed appointment.
If your business is dealing with a complex workplace issue or has received a WRC complaint, identifying the relevant obligations and available options early can help avoid further difficulties.
Need guidance on an employment matter?
Contact Employment Matters to arrange an initial conversation with our team and discuss whether we can assist.
WRC Case Reference: ADJ-00049248
Complaint Reference: CA-00060524-001
Parties: Gerry Burke v Magellan Aviation Services
Legislation: Unfair Dismissals Acts 1977–2015
Decision Date: 6 October 2026
Adjudication Officer: Ewa Sobanska
Award: €41,434.08 net
Official WRC Decision: https://www.workplacerelations.ie/en/cases/2026/october/adj-00049248/
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. The appropriate legal obligations and procedures depend on the circumstances of each employment situation.
