A recent Labour Court decision serves as a stark reminder to employers of the importance of following fair procedures when dismissing an employee. The case involved Eurodeck Ltd, a company operating in the industrial decking sector, and a former production manager who was let go in a manner the court described as entirely lacking due process.
Background of the Case
The complainant, a production manager with decades of industry experience, had moved from Cork to Laois in early 2022 to take up the role with Eurodeck. However, less than a year into the position, a disagreement with the company’s owner over a shipping deadline led to a sudden and abrupt dismissal. The employee was told to “get in your car and leave,” with no warning, no disciplinary process, and no opportunity to respond to the concerns raised.
Despite repeated attempts to resolve the situation through communication, the employee never received formal notification of dismissal or any documentation relating to their employment rights. He was left in limbo, unsure whether he had been terminated or suspended.
Labour Court Findings
Initially, the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) had awarded the employee €5,000 in compensation. However, he appealed to the Labour Court, which found that the dismissal had been procedurally flawed from start to finish.
The Labour Court noted several key failings:
- No written terms of employment were ever provided to the employee, a breach of the Terms of Employment (Information) Act.
- There was no disciplinary or dismissal process followed, contrary to the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977.
- The manner of dismissal was described as “abrupt, humiliating and legally indefensible.”
The Court concluded that the employee had suffered serious emotional and financial distress and determined that the original WRC award did not reflect the severity of the employer’s actions.
Compensation Award
Taking all factors into account, the Labour Court recommended that Eurodeck Ltd pay the complainant €40,000—equivalent to approximately six months of his annual salary. This amount was deemed “fair and equitable” in light of the circumstances, including the employee’s relocation and the impact on his livelihood and dignity.
Lessons for Employers
This ruling highlights the critical importance of following lawful and fair procedures when dismissing staff. Employers should take note of the following best practices to avoid similar outcomes:
✅ Provide Written Terms of Employment: This is not only a best practice—it’s a legal requirement.
✅ Follow a Fair Disciplinary Process: Employees must be given notice, a chance to respond, and access to representation.
✅ Handle Dismissals Professionally: Abrupt or disrespectful dismissals can result in higher compensation awards.
✅ Document Everything: Ensure that key decisions and processes are clearly recorded.
Failure to follow these steps can not only harm your employee relationships but also lead to significant financial and reputational damage.
Final Thoughts
This case is a powerful reminder that employment law is not just about compliance—it’s about treating people with fairness and dignity. If you’re an employer unsure about your obligations when it comes to dismissal, redundancy, or employee grievances, our team at Employment Matters is here to help.
Stay informed with the latest in employment law—follow our blog or get in touch with us for expert guidance tailored to your business.
